S-Corporations: Election, Salary, and Basis
How to Elect S-Corp Status: Form 2553 Step by Step
Electing S status takes one form and one signature per shareholder, yet it is one of the most commonly botched filings in small business tax. Deadlines are short, mistakes are subtle, and the consequences (a business taxed differently than the owner expected) can run for years. This guide covers the mechanics and the common failure points.
What the election does
An S election tells the IRS to tax a corporation (or an LLC that has chosen to be classified as a corporation) as a pass-through. The entity files Form 1120-S, and income flows to shareholders' returns on Schedules K-1. It does not create a legal entity. It is a tax status layered on top of a corporation or LLC. For the big picture see LLC vs S-corp vs C-corp.
Before you file: confirm eligibility
The company must be a domestic entity, have no more than 100 shareholders, have only eligible shareholders, and issue only one class of stock. Certain financial institutions and some other entities cannot elect. All owners, not just the majority, must consent. Read S-corp eligibility rules before you file, because an election made by an ineligible company is invalid from the start.
The deadline
For an election to take effect at the start of a calendar tax year, the form must generally be filed no later than March 15 (two months and 15 days after January 1). For a new company, the two-month-and-15-day window runs from the date the company first has shareholders, acquires assets, or begins doing business, whichever is earliest. Filing early is also allowed: you can file in the year before the year for which the election is to be effective.
Because deadlines look at the beginning of the tax year or the entity's first day, owners who form an LLC in February and wait until summer to think about S status are frequently already late for the current year.
Filling out Form 2553
The form is short, but each field matters:
- Entity information. Legal name, address, EIN, and date and state of incorporation or organization. The name must match IRS records.
- Effective date. The date the election begins. If you file late without relief, the IRS may treat the effective date as the next year.
- Tax year. Most small businesses use a calendar year. A different tax year requires additional reasoning and is unusual.
- Shareholder information. Name, address, taxpayer ID, number of shares, and dates acquired for each shareholder.
- Consent signatures. Every person who is a shareholder on the day the election is made, and anyone who was a shareholder during the period before the election, must sign. In community property states, spouses generally sign too.
- Officer signature. An authorized officer signs, under penalties of perjury.
LLCs filing Form 2553 do not also need Form 8832. The IRS treats the LLC as having elected to be taxed as a corporation for the purpose of the S election, as long as it meets the requirements.
Where and how to file
Form 2553 is filed with the IRS service center listed in the instructions for the state where the entity is located, and the instructions describe fax and mail options. Keep proof of filing. The IRS generally responds with an acceptance letter (often a CP261 notice) after processing, which can take several weeks. Save that letter permanently. If you never receive one, follow up with the IRS rather than assuming all is well.
If you missed the deadline
The IRS provides a late election relief procedure for companies that intended to be an S-corp and can show reasonable cause for failing to file on time. In general terms, relief is available if the entity meets several conditions: it intended to be an S-corp from the requested date, it filed all required returns consistently with S treatment, no shareholder reported inconsistently, and the request is made within a set period after the intended effective date (currently generally three years and 75 days). The request is made by filing Form 2553 with a statement of reasonable cause and the required language, and the instructions explain the details.
Relief is not guaranteed and it is not a plan. Some businesses discover they have been filing 1120-S returns for years without a valid election, which leads to complex cleanups. If you suspect this, see our entity cleanup guide and involve a professional.
After the IRS accepts
The election is not the finish line. Several actions follow:
- Start payroll for owner-employees. Owners who perform services must be paid reasonable compensation through payroll for the S-corp period. See S-corp payroll for owner-employees.
- Set up distributions correctly. Distributions must be proportionate to ownership. See S-corp distributions.
- Change your bookkeeping. You need accounts for shareholder distributions, shareholder loans, and payroll expense. See bookkeeping systems for small businesses.
- File Form 1120-S annually. It is due March 15 for calendar-year filers, with extensions available. Late penalties are assessed per shareholder per month. See Form 1120-S guide.
- Adjust estimated taxes. With payroll withholding covering some tax, the estimate calculation changes.
- Review state registrations. Some states require a separate state election or entity-level filing.
Common mistakes that invalidate or complicate an election
- A shareholder who is not eligible, such as a partnership, a corporation, or a nonresident alien.
- Missing signatures. A missing shareholder consent can invalidate the election unless relief is requested.
- Filing before the entity exists or before it has an EIN.
- Not filing at all, but sending in an 1120-S anyway.
- Assuming a state filing makes you an S-corp. State formation and IRS elections are separate.
- Never starting payroll, leaving compensation issues for later.
- Ignoring the built-in gains rules when converting from a C-corp. See changing entity type.
Revoking or terminating
An election continues until it is revoked or terminated. Revocation requires consent of shareholders holding more than half of the shares and a statement filed with the IRS. Termination happens automatically if the company stops qualifying. After termination or revocation, the company generally cannot re-elect for five years without consent from the IRS.
Working with a professional
If you are unsure about eligibility or timing, or if a late relief request is involved, involve a tax professional before filing. AE Tax Advisors works through election timing with owners regularly, and you can begin with a discovery call. And if you are still deciding whether to elect at all, read when to elect S-corp status first.